PART 1: What instructional approaches matter most?

We are often bombarded with research claims in education.  The reality is that many of these claims are shaky, unsubstantiated, or even false.   However, some researchers have attempted to make some sense of the often contradictory evidence.  See how your intuition or experience align with the research base below.

Below is a list of 30 influences on student learning.  Rate your estimate of their impacts based on the research base.  (Answers at the end of the post).

Influence Impact                                      Impact

Ability grouping/tracking/streaming                                               High Medium   Low
Acceleration (for example skipping a year)                                    High Medium   Low
Comprehension programs                                                                  High Medium   Low
Concept mapping                                                                                   High Medium   Low
Cooperative vs. individualistic learning                                           High Medium   Low
Direct instruction                                                                                     High Medium   Low
Feedback                                                                                                     High Medium   Low
Gender (male vs female achievement)                                              High Medium   Low
Home environment                                                                                 High Medium   Low
Individualizing instruction                                                                     High Medium   Low
Influence of peers                                                                                     High Medium   Low
Matching teaching with student learning style                              High Medium   Low
Meta-cognitive strategy programs                                                     High Medium   Low
Phonics instruction                                                                                  High Medium   Low
Professional development on student achievement                   High Medium   Low
Providing formative evaluation to teachers                                    High Medium   Low
Providing worked examples                                                                  High Medium   Low
Reciprocal teaching                                                                                   High Medium   Low
Reducing class size                                                                                    High Medium   Low
Retention (holding back a year)                                                           High Medium   Low
Student control over learning                                                               High Medium   Low
Student expectations                                                                               High Medium   Low
Teacher credibility in eyes of student                                                 High Medium   Low
Teacher expectations                                                                               High Medium   Low
Teacher subject matter knowledge                                                     High Medium   Low
Teacher-student relationships                                                              High Medium   Low
Using simulations and gaming                                                              High Medium   Low
Vocabulary programs                                                                               High Medium   Low
Whole language programs                                                                      High Medium   Low
Within-class grouping                                                                               High Medium   Low

I have been reading a, recently published, book by John Hattie, Visible Learning for Teachers, Maximizing Impact on Learning (2012).   This is a followup to Hattie’s Visible Learning, the largest synthesis and collection of evidence-based research on what actually works in schools to improve learning.  Visible Learning for Teachers was written to bring this synthesis to teachers.  It has proven to be more interesting and nuanced than Marzano’s Classroom Instruction that Works, maybe because it doesn’t feel like Hattie is selling a product or system of products.  Editorials aside, I would strongly recommend this to teachers wishing to investigate what the research says on teaching.

Much of his scholarship deals with the synthesis of meta-analyses of research.  This work involved more than 800 meta-analyses of 50,000 research studies involving 240 million students.  Out of these Hattie and others have settled on studies that show an effect size of 0.4 as being worthy of replication (an effect size is described below for those wanting to get all statistical).  An effect size of 0.4 is considered significant as it is the mean effect size of all 50,000 studies and also turns out to be the average effect of a year of schooling on a student’s learning.  In fact students in younger grades show an effect size slightly above this and students in higher grades slightly below this for a year of schooling.

The results for the influences above are based on Hattie’s research, influences that were classified as low impacts had effects sizes below 0.3, medium between 0.3-0.6, and high above 0.6.  See how your intuition and the research literature align here.

What is an effect size?

An effect size quantifies the difference between two groups.  It allows researchers and consumers of research to move beyond asking questions such as “does it work” to questions such as “how well does it work”?  Thus a large effect size indicates not only that the effect is significant, but the importance with which we should view the treatment.  This measure takes into account the amount of variability within the two compared groups.  The more variability, the greater the difference between the averages for both groups must be for the effect size to be large.

A significant medium effect size is considered to be between 0.3-0.6.  One important aspect of using effect sizes is that it allows researchers like Hattie to compare different studies, using different measures, to one another in a fair manner.

Looking for more go here.

READ POST 2 to see what the research base supports as the most effective strategies (go here).


About shawncarlson

Assistant Superintendent
This entry was posted in AOS 98, BRES, BRHS, Edgecomb, Georgetown, Instruction, Southport and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to PART 1: What instructional approaches matter most?

  1. Marcelle Durost says:

    This is a great reminder of what is truly effective instructional approaches as we plan and implement instructional strategies within our daily work!

  2. Pingback: What elements of Domain 1 provide the greatest impact on student achievement? | Rocky Channels Central Office Blog

  3. Pingback: Visible Learning for Teachers | Rocky Channels Central Office Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s